For me, the sight of an 83-year-old, former Egyptian president and hero of the October 1973 War lying ill on a stretcher in a courtroom cage as one of his sons bent down to kiss him was hard to watch. And I’m sure that many Egyptians, even those who were glad to see him go, feel the same way. On the other hand, provided this historic trial brings closure it is a necessary part of the transformational process.
Strangely, the accused – Hosni Mubarak, his sons Ala’a and Gamal and former Interior Minister Habib Al-Adly – appeared more dignified than the attorneys milling around the courtroom most of whom were there to register civilian cases on behalf of their clients.
Such undisciplined and noisy scenes didn’t reflect well on Egyptian justice in the eyes of billions of viewers and, unfortunately were grist to the mill of Arab critics such as Moshe Dayan who’s been quoted as saying, “If the Arabs cannot organize their shoes in front of the mosques when they go for prayer, which is the bare minimum, then they have no hope for them…”
More importantly, the trial should be fair unlike the kangaroo court in Iraq that sent Saddam Hussein to the gallows; it should set the standard for justice in post-revolutionary .
Verdicts should be passed by impartial judges based on hard evidence. My fear is that Mubarak’s day in court will become a political show trial with judges either riding the revolutionary wave themselves or under pressure to please the crowds on the street. If that’s the case, Mubarak and others should be tried by an international tribunal.
I want to see strong, stable and united under a pluralistic political system - and, as the largest Arab country, able to reassert its role as a regional key player. But I fear that the people’s current obsession with retribution and promotion of sectarian interests may be harming those goals.
If some interpret my valid concerns as sympathy for the old regime they are wrong. For instance, my column titled “An impatient minority holds hostage” was one of the articles discussed last week on the BBC’s “7 Days’ program; in particular my assertion that unknown know-it-alls are appearing on Arabic networks falsely claiming a mandate to speak on behalf of the Egyptian people. It’s my view that until parliamentary and presidential elections are held in the late autumn nobody has that right.
One of the BBC’s guests was Abdullah Hamouda, an Egyptian journalist based in London, who reacted to the excerpt from my column saying, “Everyone sees what is happening through their own eyes, from their point of view and through their own interests.” The host sought to clarify his statement by asking, “You mean that the papers have interest? The Gulf papers you mean and the attitudes in them?”
“Yes, I mean what Al Habtoor, the businessman, said reflects the attitude and position of businessmen in the Gulf who came to in the time of the old regime and who received all the privileges and all the special treatments at the time and their ability to deal with the corrupted people who were controlling everything at that time,” he replied.
“Unfortunately, many of them accomplished a lot this way. I wish that a man like Khalaf Al Habtoor, who is a businessman with a lot of interests in a lot of countries, wouldn’t speak in this way. Everyone should see what is happening from the Egyptian people’s point of view and what the Egyptian people want, not what these people [outsiders] want.”
To set the record straight, I have never met former President Mubarak, his family or any others accused. I have never been the beneficiary of special treatment or privilege from officialdom during my visits to the country and I have no business interests in .
It seems to me that Mr. Hamouda has fallen into the category of so-called experts believing they know what the Egyptian people want and who are unwilling even to listen to the advice of ’s friends who are away from the fire and might, therefore, possess greater objectivity.
Actually, it isn’t so much what Egyptians want as what they need, which are basically the same needs as people everywhere especially the ability to hold their heads high, The fact is that Egyptians are diametrically divided. The youth movement wants a Western-style democracy run by a civilian government with no military oversight. Copts want greater political representation and the right to construct churches. Secularists and modernists want an open society and a government in which religion plays no part.
Then there are the Islamist organizations such as the Muslim Brotherhood (MB) which did its best to hide its true objectives during the revolution’s aftermath promising not to field a presidential candidate or to target more than 30 percent of all parliamentary seats while having launched a PR campaign to display its new moderate, all-encompassing face. Since, the layers have peeled off. The MB has formed a coalition with Islamist extremist groups and spawned new parties headed by staunch ‘former’ MB leaders who are going after the presidency.
The veil dropped off the MB on Friday July 29th when its members together with other Islamists called for the creation of an Islamic state under Sharia law, chanting “Islam, Islam, we do not want a liberal state” with a few holding up photographs of Osama bin Laden.
As is predominantly Muslim it is only right that Islamic principles are taken into account by the state, but these fanatics want a kind of Sunni Islamic Republic of Iran that would result in ’s international isolation, economic disaster and an end to personal freedoms. If this happens, the Egyptian leadership could look to Tehran for political and economic support, and fall under the ayatollahs’ sway in the same way as Iraq, Syria and Lebanon have done.
Now they’ve finally shown their true colours, I hope the Egyptian people will understand just how dangerous they are. Iranian delegations have already begun regularly visiting for discussions with political and religious entities.
urgently needs a firm, principled captain but until then the military must stop kowtowing to demonstrators without real vision hanging about on the streets and give the Islamists a red line that cannot be crossed.
Just as it was the military that ousted King Farouk in 1952 and bravely defended against foreign aggression it must step-up now to prevent its own ship sinking taking the rest of us down with it. Egyptians are in the fight of their lives and if they’re unable to see that then it’s the duty of people like me, a proud Arab who has always loved , to help open their eyes.